Carter's Carpet Restoration

Serving Placerville, El Dorado Hills, Folsom, Granite Bay, Cameron Park & Surrounding Areas

Hours of Operation

Mon - Fri: 8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Sat: By Appointment
Sunday: Closed

Call Us Today

El Dorado Hills: (916) 933-7807
Placerville: (530) 642-9003

Restoration Vs Replacement Of Carpet


restoration vs replacement of carpet

Restoration VS Replacement of Carpet 

In this post, you will learn the benefits of restoration VS replacement of carpet. Read along to learn everything you need to know about what is right for you. 

Are you comparing the pros and cons of restoration vs replacement of carpet in your California home or business? Are you stuck trying to decide whether or not your carpet can be saved, or if it’s just time to let it go and replace it?  If so, you’ve come to the right place!  

Did you know that, on average, carpeting is considered to be the third-largest investment an individual will make, right behind investing in a home and purchase of a vehicle? When approaching the question of replacement or restoring your existing carpet, it’s important to have all the facts before making a decision. 

In this article, we’ll provide you with the pros and cons of both restoration and replacement, along with some helpful tips for each option to guide you in making the right choice for your California location.  

should i restore or replace carpeting?

How To Know Whether To Restore Or Replace Your Carpeting

Cost Comparison


When weighing the cost of restoration of your current carpeting in comparison to replacing it, restoration is a far less expensive option. On average, fixing damage to your existing carpet costs between $150.00-$250.00 on average. In comparison, replacing the carpet in your home runs between $400.00-$1,500.00 per room. Even if you take into account the costs of cleaning the existing carpet, the choice to restore your carpeting is far less costly than fully replacing it. 


Carpet Lifespan

Another factor to take into consideration is the age of your current carpet. On average, it is recommended that carpeting be replaced after nine years of use. And of course, during that time period you should invest in regular carpet cleaning.

As you know, it could be a waste of time and money to repair carpeting that will only need replacing a short time later.  If the existing carpet has outlived its expected lifespan, it may be more reasonable to replace it. 

However, if the carpet is in a relatively low traffic area and isn’t showing significant signs of wear or damage, you may still choose to have it repaired. A repair is also a good option if you are preparing a property for sale, as it will improve the overall appearance of the interior while keeping your renovation costs to a minimum.  

PRO TIP: On a side note, you can learn more about the restoration of other types of flooring too.  Read about travertine floor restoration in addition to restoring or replacing carpet.  We know carpeting isn’t the only type of flooring in your home.

Severity of Damage

If your carpet is heavily worn or damaged, a replacement may be your only option. Carpets with large spots of heavy wear, burns, and fraying may not be able to be fixed. Additionally, carpeting that creaks or groans when you walk on it is showing signs that the padding that supports your carpet may be worn out. Worn-out carpet padding is a clear indication that your carpet is in need of a replacement.  


In the case of incidents such as stubborn odors from pets or severe allergies that no amount of deep cleaning seems to resolve, your best bet is to replace your carpeting. In the long run, it will save you both time and money.   


Replacement is also your best option in the case of water damage, as there is no way to tell for sure how much of your carpet has been impacted. You also face the threat of mold growth going unchecked under your carpeting and potentially causing severe illness in addition to significant and irreversible damage to the flooring in your home or business.     


Appearance and Aesthetics


If your carpet is old, outdated, or just plain ugly, it may be worth considering an update to improve the appearance of your home or business by replacing the carpet. It is important to consider whether or not you like your existing carpet enough to have it repaired or if you would prefer something new and more modern in your space. 


New carpeting may be just what you need to uplift your home’s overall appearance and add value to your property. It is worth taking into account that new carpeting adds to your property’s equity and improves the resale value. 


But, you also have to weigh the overall hassle to replace your carpeting as well. A full replacement involves a lot of time and effort whether you are hiring a company to install your new carpeting or you intend to do it yourself. Repairing the existing carpet is a more manageable option if the overall goal is simply to improve the look of your floors. 


Lifestyle Changes 


Significant changes in your lifestyle should also be considered in your decision to replace or simply repair your carpet. You may have recently purchased your home or made the decision to renovate your space. If the existing carpet is not to your personal tastes, a replacement may be in order. 


Other lifestyle changes such as the addition of young children or a new pet may sway your decision in favor of restoring your carpet rather than replacing it. It may be prudent to put off the replacement for a more settled time in the future when the kids are older, and the puppy is house trained!


Wrapping It Up


Ultimately, it all comes down to your individual needs and preference. With the help of this article, you are prepared to make a confident choice between restoration vs replacement of your carpet. If you live in the El Dorado Hills, California area, Carter’s Carpet is your best bet for finding a solution to your carpet, upholstery, and floor cleaning needs. 


Share this post

We're Ready to Help!

Call us, and we'll be there to help!

At Carter’s Carpet Restoration we offer 100% free estimates! Call us or complete our quote form.